New Computer

I recently have acquired funds that will allow me to purchase a new computer. Looking for suggestions on what is out there to get. Of course my primary software that I use would be Carrara, but also Adobe Photoshop, Illustrator, After Effects, and Dreamweaver. I currently use an old Dell XPS 8700 (i7-4790 CPU, 16 GB ram, NVIDIA GeForce GTX 745). Looking for a workstation that will get me better render times as I output 30 frames at 300 dpi from business card size up to 24"x36". I really don't want to put one together (even though it might be cheaper). Looking into a $800 to $1,200 range. Anyone have any suggestions?

Thanks, Stuie

Comments

  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    The worst of times ever, to buy a graphics card, due to a mining craze. This pretty much limits you to a pre-built big brand system like Lenovo or Dell, that can get their hands on graphics cards. In normal times, I would get the 16 core AMD Ryzen 5950x, 32GB RAM, a fast NVME drive for Windows/apps and probably the Nvidia RTX 3060 12GB. You can shave off 100$ with the older 3950x 16 core. Not sure if Intels older 18 core 10980x can be found now and it need at least 850W PSU, a budget buster...
  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    Ebay has some used HP Z840 Workstations for that budget with decent performance, if you look around.
  • StuieStuie Posts: 58

    I'll check it out.

  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    edited June 2021
    Curveball, looking at a laptop that fits desktop Ryzens like the 3950x, the XMG Apex 15 comes with an RTX 2070 mobile. It is an OEM laptop design from Clevo I think that is sold under many names around the world. The CPU is downclocked a notch to fit the mobile cooling and the current model is the previous gen 3950x/RTX2070, but it also means sales... The 12core 3900x fits better here.
    Post edited by 3drendero on
  • WendyLuvsCatzWendyLuvsCatz Posts: 38,223

    you don't need a fancy graphics card for Carrara though unless you use Octane render.

    I also found number of threads doesn't matter as much as clockspeed, thats the thing to prioritise, more RAM too for loading scenes, not as important for rendering them.

  • ed3Ded3D Posts: 2,194

    And just because  ~

    Refurbished & Overstock Laptops, Gaming Desktop PCs: Dell Outlet
      https://www.dell.com/en-us/dfh/shop/refurbished/cp/outlet-dfh

    _   thanx

  • UnifiedBrainUnifiedBrain Posts: 3,588

    Stuie, a lot of good information here:  https://www.daz3d.com/forums/discussion/comment/5086626/

    My new 3900x machine was close to your upper price range.  I did get a used video card on Craigslist which brought down the price.

    For Carrara, it is a joy to use.  Fast, and 24 buckets makes a big difference (previously I had 4).

  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,574

    I build my Carrara machines using yesteryear's great technology, since I'm always in that same price range as you are.

    My current machine uses a 2nd Generation Ryzen 7, which has 8 multi-thread cores so I get 16 threads speeding those render buckets.

     

    Building a PC can be quite fullfilling because we can pick and choose what goes in - where to save $ and where not to. For example, I went with a decent motherboard, CPU and RAM - although they were the previous generations to save coin. I also got a decent, but not super high end graphics card but that's a crazy mess right now. Luckily, Carrara doesn't care. As long as it supports OpenGL we're good - unless we're using a separate plugin like Octane.

     

    That's where buying a PC might be the best option right now - it'll come with a graphics card! LOL

    In case you'd like to consider building, I have an article I've written years ago after building my previous computer. It might help with your consideration at least:

    ► How to Build Your Own Carrara Workstation

  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    The Ryzen 5900x 12 core seems to be the best bang for the buck right now, around 600$ and close to the older 16 core 3950x in performance. Microcenter has them in store with coupon for the mainboard. Air cooling is enough, no need for water.
  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    edited June 2021
    Microcenter has B550 mainbords for 75-80$ with the coupon. 32GB RAM for 150$. There is a 3900x bundle with mainboard and cooler for 550$ too.
    Post edited by 3drendero on
  • StuieStuie Posts: 58

    Thanks so much to everyone for their input. Still waiting on the money before going with anything specific. Will let you all know where I actually go. Looking for 32GB for ram, and the AMD Ryzen 3900 sounds like the direction I want to go.

  • StuieStuie Posts: 58

    Found this, any comments? $1,647

    • CPU: AMD Ryzen 9 3900X 4.2GHz TB 12-Core 24xThreads | Liquid Cooler | 32GB DDR4 3000MHz RAM | AMD B450 motherboard
    • Video card - GeForce GT 1030 2GB | Windows 10 Pro 64bit | AC WiFi adapter
    • Storage - 2TB SSD | Fast solid state drive for OS and apps
    • Case - Raidmax i207, tempered glass side panel, USB 3.0, RGB LEDs, 3x120mm fans
  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    edited June 2021
    Here is a 1000$ 5900x rig with brand parts excl GPU. Since graphics card prices are so crazy, even the entry level cards are 4x rhe retail. Use your old card until the crypto market crashes again. https://pcpartpicker.com/list/vd3VK3 /Edit. A similar build at Microcenter is 1050$ dollars and 150$ if they build it for you. Again no GPU in stock and their choice of CPU fans is too limited.
    Post edited by 3drendero on
  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    Here is the detailed 3900x vs 5900x shootout, at rendering you get 20-25% more or basically 12 vs 15 core. But you also get the single core boost of the same, which is noticable both in Carrara and everywhere else too. https://www.anandtech.com/bench/product/2619?vs=2674
  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    The 1650$ rig above is near 2x the cost of a DIY build and has a few parts I don't like. The RAM is looks a bit slower than the optimal for Zen2 for a similar price, assuming it is SSD and not nvme that is 5x faster at the same price. The PSU is not listed, min 500W to handle a decent graphics card, when the crypto market crashes, they are going to be cheap. The mainboard is 1 gen behind the current B550, no biggie but similar price and better compatibility with the B550.
  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,574

    3drendero said:

    The 1650$ rig above is near 2x the cost of a DIY build and has a few parts I don't like. The RAM is looks a bit slower than the optimal for Zen2 for a similar price, assuming it is SSD and not nvme that is 5x faster at the same price. The PSU is not listed, min 500W to handle a decent graphics card, when the crypto market crashes, they are going to be cheap. The mainboard is 1 gen behind the current B550, no biggie but similar price and better compatibility with the B550.

    Perhaps, but without having to build, it seems like a fair price and it will certainly Rock Carrara!

    I bought one of those graphics cards a while back after mine burnt out and, while it did work for most budget games and such (just checked them out to test the card - I actually don't play games often at all), but has no Cuda cores, so won't be recognized by any of your Cuda-using apps.

    Still, set those things to use your CPU until you can get your hands on a new card in the future - that Ryzen should make you happy!

     

    Like 3drendero was eluding to, we can get a much higher bang for the buck if we don't mind doing our own builds. For example, I always look for a case that has filters for the intake fans to keep my fans healthy longer and don't put as much coin towards the things that I don't need, etc.,

     

    This last built was the first time that I went with the full version of Windows instead of a slightly less expensive OEM version, and I love it So Much More!!! No spamware except for the Microsoft stuff - Office 360, etc., etc.,

    Never going OEM again, if I can help it!

     

    But for what it's worth, that Ryzen you're looking at will blow mine away - and I am absolutely Thrilled with mine!

    At 28 seconds into this video, I show Carrara rendering in real time with screen capture on - and it's a fairly complex scene with seven characters, lots of lights and a decent amount of interior scene geometry.

  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    Here is another new product that has made self builds easier. Thermal pad for CPU that works well, easy to install and re-usable. No need to mess with thermal paste any more. Cool name too. https://www.microcenter.com/product/607607/thermal-grizzly-carbonaut-thermal-pad,-32-×-32-×-02-mm
  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    The 1030 card (in stock at Microcenter too now) seems to be about 20% of 1080 when looking at speed and RAM size. It should also run any CUDA apps that fit into the small 2GB but slowly. https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/geforce-gt-1030.c2954
  • DartanbeckDartanbeck Posts: 21,574

    I must admit - the first time I built my own computer I was really nervous about it. Ever since, it's the only way to go for me.

    I love that new CPU thermal pad! Although I've never minded using my Arctic Silver.

     

    Yes we need to take measures against static and, Yes we need to be mindful as we assemble everything and, most importantly, Yes we need to make sure that we're ordering parts that will work with each other... but all of that is part of the thrill!

     

    Each time I've built my own, I made sure to get a nice, roomy tower for maximum airflow - and each of them had filtered intake housings for the fans. My computers stay nice and new inside.

     

    With my Ryzen and my previous Zambezi, I didn't even use an aftermarket CPU cooler. The WraithSpire cooler of the Ryzen keeps my cores nice and cool - and I render for days on end, with the CPU power settings set to Ultimate, so it runs all sixteen threads at 100% when I'm rendering. I love that it stays at a nice temp! Of course, I did put it all in a nice, roomy case with all 120mm silent fans (even one behind the motherboard!) except for a 240mm exhaust fan on the top, which came with the case. My Antec came with a filtered front for up to 3 120mm intake fans, an intake filter for the power supply, and a beautifully spacious gap behind the motherboard for cable management.

     

    So that's all part of the fun of building - getting great parts to build a great machine for a much better deal than buying a complete machine.

     

    My Zambezi was an eight core without hyper-threading, so it was also eight threads. My 16GB RAM was fine for that Win7 64 bit machine.

     

    Knowing that Win10 likes to use up RAM without even asking, I went with 64GB on my Ryzen build. I barely touch that. So far it's been overkill and 32 GB would have been fine.

  • MistaraMistara Posts: 38,675

     

  • StezzaStezza Posts: 8,066

    I built a Ryzen9 monster machine for my bro in law about a month ago for his flight sim program ( he is 74 years old ) ... was the first time he experienced a build and I hadn't done one for a few years...

    what a machine though!

  • From that price range you won't find any good stuff right now.
    The question also is if you use Octane for Carrara or not, some graphic cards does not support Octane below 2020 (GTX 16 Series for example).

    I am also still looking for some stuff, first i wanted to spend lots of money for a complete new System but also thinking about updating my actual system but right now everything gots very expensive, so i would think next year things will look better to get something newer.

  • StuieStuie Posts: 58

    OMG, this is worse than waiting to afford a better system. I went ahead and did the upgrade for a new system with the AMD Ryzen, etc. I got it last week, but with one huge problem. I got it a day after I got my shoulder replacement surgery, so now instead of having it set up I'm just looking at the box it came in, not even able to unpack it. I'll just have to sit back next few weeks looking at it and wipe the drool from my mouth in anticipation. Oh well, timing was just a bit off. Thanks everyone for the suggestions and feedback.

    One last thing, I got my shoulder surgery on my birthday. What's even weirdier, it was in the same hospital I was born in 68 years ago.

  • 3drendero3drendero Posts: 2,024
    Congratulations for the birthday and good presents.
Sign In or Register to comment.